Decision-making can be quite complex. Facing a wealth of considerations regarding difficult alternatives, it may be hard to know what the best thing to do is, and which principles should guide the choice. For this reason, instruments like cost-benefit analysis and multi-criteria analysis have been developed to help in the process by assessing the relevant alternatives. The role that this type of evaluative instruments should have in the decision-making process, however, is debated (Lami, Moroni, 2020). Their intuitive and traditional role has been to identify the overall best option: they include all the relevant considerations and then, on the basis of some norms of rationality, they select an optimal solution. However, evaluative instruments can also function as “decision-aiding” techniques: in this role, their main contribution is to help structure the decision, rather than recommending some uniquely rational course of action. But what this decision-aiding role amounts to needs to be clarified (Lami, Moroni, 2020). In this paper, we argue that the main difference between the traditional role and the decision-aiding one is that decision-aiding techniques do not assume that the inputs of the decision problem are well-defined. The traditional view assumes that inputs like preferences are pre-existing, external objects that need only be appropriately represented in the model of the decision – an assumption which has largely been challenged by behavioural economics and experimental decision theory. Instead, decision-aiding techniques can work as a guiding instrument through decision-making processes with ill-defined inputs. We will first illustrate what we mean when we say that traditional approaches assume that decision problems are well-defined, and then we will build on this to clarify the role of evaluative instruments in decision-making.

Il ruolo degli strumenti valutativi nel processo decisionale

M. Ongaro;D. Chiffi;P. Janda
2025-01-01

Abstract

Decision-making can be quite complex. Facing a wealth of considerations regarding difficult alternatives, it may be hard to know what the best thing to do is, and which principles should guide the choice. For this reason, instruments like cost-benefit analysis and multi-criteria analysis have been developed to help in the process by assessing the relevant alternatives. The role that this type of evaluative instruments should have in the decision-making process, however, is debated (Lami, Moroni, 2020). Their intuitive and traditional role has been to identify the overall best option: they include all the relevant considerations and then, on the basis of some norms of rationality, they select an optimal solution. However, evaluative instruments can also function as “decision-aiding” techniques: in this role, their main contribution is to help structure the decision, rather than recommending some uniquely rational course of action. But what this decision-aiding role amounts to needs to be clarified (Lami, Moroni, 2020). In this paper, we argue that the main difference between the traditional role and the decision-aiding one is that decision-aiding techniques do not assume that the inputs of the decision problem are well-defined. The traditional view assumes that inputs like preferences are pre-existing, external objects that need only be appropriately represented in the model of the decision – an assumption which has largely been challenged by behavioural economics and experimental decision theory. Instead, decision-aiding techniques can work as a guiding instrument through decision-making processes with ill-defined inputs. We will first illustrate what we mean when we say that traditional approaches assume that decision problems are well-defined, and then we will build on this to clarify the role of evaluative instruments in decision-making.
2025
Oltrerischio. Dalla resilienza all'antifragilità: Architetture, pratiche, comunità
979-12-5644-136-5
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Pagine da Oltrerischio_interno+cover.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 1.69 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.69 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11311/1299390
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
  • OpenAlex ND
social impact