: The tradeoff between speed and accuracy is a well-known constraint for human movement, but previous work has shown that this tradeoff can be modified by practice, and the quantitative relationship between speed and accuracy may be an indicator of skill in some tasks. We have previously shown that children with dystonia are able to adapt their movement strategy in a ballistic throwing game to compensate for increased variability of movement. Here, we test whether children with dystonia can adapt and improve skills learned on a trajectory task. We use a novel task in which children move a spoon with a marble between two targets. Difficulty is modified by changing the depth of the spoon. Our results show that both healthy children and children with acquired dystonia move more slowly with the more difficult spoons, and both groups improve the relationship between speed and spoon difficulty following 1 wk of practice. By tracking the marble position in the spoon, we show that children with dystonia use a larger fraction of the available variability, whereas healthy children adopt a much safer strategy and remain farther from the margins, as well as learning to adapt and have more control over the marble's utilized area by practice. Together, our results show that both healthy children and children with dystonia choose trajectories that compensate for risk and inherent variability, and that the increased variability in dystonia can be modified with continued practice.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study provides insights into the adaptability of children with dystonia in learning a point-to-point task. We show that these children adjust their strategies to account for increased difficulty in the task. Our findings underscore the potential of task-specific practice in improving motor skills and show higher level of signal-dependent noise can be controlled through repetition and learned strategies, which provides an avenue for the quantitative evaluation of rehabilitation strategies in this challenging group.

Improvement of speed-accuracy tradeoff during practice of a point-to-point task in children with acquired dystonia

Biffi, Emilia;Ambrosini, Emilia;Pedrocchi, Alessandra;
2023-01-01

Abstract

: The tradeoff between speed and accuracy is a well-known constraint for human movement, but previous work has shown that this tradeoff can be modified by practice, and the quantitative relationship between speed and accuracy may be an indicator of skill in some tasks. We have previously shown that children with dystonia are able to adapt their movement strategy in a ballistic throwing game to compensate for increased variability of movement. Here, we test whether children with dystonia can adapt and improve skills learned on a trajectory task. We use a novel task in which children move a spoon with a marble between two targets. Difficulty is modified by changing the depth of the spoon. Our results show that both healthy children and children with acquired dystonia move more slowly with the more difficult spoons, and both groups improve the relationship between speed and spoon difficulty following 1 wk of practice. By tracking the marble position in the spoon, we show that children with dystonia use a larger fraction of the available variability, whereas healthy children adopt a much safer strategy and remain farther from the margins, as well as learning to adapt and have more control over the marble's utilized area by practice. Together, our results show that both healthy children and children with dystonia choose trajectories that compensate for risk and inherent variability, and that the increased variability in dystonia can be modified with continued practice.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study provides insights into the adaptability of children with dystonia in learning a point-to-point task. We show that these children adjust their strategies to account for increased difficulty in the task. Our findings underscore the potential of task-specific practice in improving motor skills and show higher level of signal-dependent noise can be controlled through repetition and learned strategies, which provides an avenue for the quantitative evaluation of rehabilitation strategies in this challenging group.
2023
Fitts’ law
dystonia
motor learning
risk aware control
speed-accuracy tradeoff
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
kasiri-et-al-2023-improvement-of-speed-accuracy-tradeoff-during-practice-of-a-point-to-point-task-in-children-with.pdf

accesso aperto

: Publisher’s version
Dimensione 2.06 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
2.06 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11311/1259987
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? 0
  • Scopus 0
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact