Feedback-controlled laser ablation for cancer treatment: comparison of On-Off and PID control strategies

: Laser ablation is a rising technique used to induce a localized temperature increment for tumor ablation. The outcomes of the therapy depend on the tissue thermal history. Monitoring devices help to assess the tissue thermal response, and their combination with a control strategy can be used to promptly address unexpected temperature changes and thus reduce unwanted thermal effects. In this application, numerical simulations can drive the selection of the laser control settings (i.e., laser power and gain parameters) and allow evaluating the thermal effects of the control strategies. In this study, the influence of different control strategies (On-Off and PID-based controls) is quantified considering the treatment time and the thermal effect on the tissue. Finite element model-based simulations were implemented to model the laser-tissue interaction, the heat-transfer, and the consequent thermal damage in liver tissue with tumor. The laser power was modulated based on the temperature feedback provided within the tumor safety margin. Results show that the chosen control strategy does not have a major influence on the extent of thermal damage but on the treatment duration; the percentage of necrosis within the tumor domain is 100% with both strategies, while the treatment duration is 630 s and 786 s for On-Off and PID, respectively. The choice of the control strategy is a trade-off between treatment duration and unwanted temperature overshoot during closed-loop laser ablation. Clinical Relevance-This work establishes that different temperature-based control of the laser ablation procedure does not have a major influence on the extent of thermal damage but on the duration of treatment.